Since I run it I'll say how it will be (pulling rank on mangs

) well not really but here are my 10 isk on the matter.
1. If we move to 00 and become renters with nerf in aaa. Our end goal isn't to be renters its to be fully fledged alliance members of the holding alliance.
2. What ships are by far the most wanted in the fleets? Logistics and hics (and possibly t3 boosting cruisers but anyway)
So if we are to make some kind of mark there then being able to field logis is one of the best (in my opinion). Which means a greater chance of us getting to be seen as valuable and easier to get forward.
However, a lot are returning (i hope) from hiatus and might not have extensive wallets (i know I dont) so the old system means people can afford to pvp as well. So for now I think both systems should complement each other. The replacement system hasn't exactly been used much at all anyways.
If we get to 00 and people get more money that might not matter and the system could change.
And sorry mang but the demand for logi v and large fleets is a bit difficult given our small size. but you are ofc right that for small gang stuff more dps is usually better (or a dictor if in 00)