I think we may be considerably overestimating the average WBs organizational skills. Splitting groups, differing positions are all well and good but until we've practiced the standard charge together... we aren’t going anywhere.
I’ll be honest, I'm a terribly irritating armchair general. I feel someone’s got to do it however or nothing’s going to get done. While I couldn't stay the whole night tonight (so I'm not sure how the it turned out in the end), my heart sank at the start when we should have had that keep taken if only for the ability to run up a ramp together. 4-5 destro 15 Order and we just couldn't do it.
So my sieging tip. Breaking that line of Destro and NPCs, when you see the start of the charge follow up, all the way up, right up the ramp to the other side of the room, do your job, play your ass off and either you or the keep will fall. Standing at the bottom watching everyone move up first, tentatively poking your head up and watching people die, running back down when you start to take damage... Just... NO stop blocking the ramp/stairs and bugger off! Everyone goes up; everyone fights everyone wins or everyone dies!
I'm all for a good bit of tactics, focus fire and all the add-ons in the world but if we can't advance "da plan" past 5 defenders and some stairs then we've no chance of trying something even a little complicated.
My apologies if this sounds a little ranty but I often see some awesome teamwork occuring in scenarios that dosn't seem to follow order out onto the feild, gets my goat a little.